THREE’S COMPANY PART FOUR: THE WOMAN IN THE MIRROR

“Who are you?” Denise asked, tightening the towel around her body.
Tonya stood in the doorway, looking from Denise to Samuel.
“Girl, the better question is, who the hell are YOU?”
Denise folded her arms.“Excuse me? You're standing in MY house!” Tonya laughed.
“Oh, so this is YOUR house? Samuel, you got about five seconds to explain what the hell is going on.”
Samuel reached for his shirt.“Tonya, just calm down.” “CALM DOWN? Samuel, I've been calling your ass for two days! TWO DAYS! And now I'm standing here looking at another woman wrapped in a towel while you're walking around half-naked?”
Denise looked at Samuel. “Wait a minute. Did she just say her name is Tonya?” Tonya rolled her eyes.
“Yes, sweetheart. TONYA. Now, can somebody tell me what the hell is going on?”
Denise shook her head. “Oh, Samuel. You have got to be kidding me.”
“Denise, please,” Samuel replied.
“No! Don't Denise me! You promised me we weren't going through this again.” Tonya looked between them.
“Again? Oh, now this is getting interesting. What exactly are we not going through again?” Neither answered.
“Oh, so now everybody wants to be quiet? Ain't that something.”
Samuel stepped toward Tonya.“Baby, listen..”
“Don't baby me! You better start talking before I start putting two and two together, and trust me, Samuel, you don't want me doing the math!”
Denise disappeared into the bedroom. Tonya turned toward Samuel. “So what is she? Your girlfriend? Wife? Side chick? What?”
“She's my cousin, Tonya.”
Tonya stared at him.
“Your cousin?”
“Yes.”
“Samuel, don't play with me. Because the way she's carrying on, either y'all got some family issues or somebody's lying.”
Before Samuel could respond, Denise returned holding a photograph.
“Here. Maybe this will help.”Tonya snatched the picture from her hand. She looked down.
There they were. Samuel. Denise. And herself.
All three were sitting together at a restaurant. Tonya's smile disappeared.
“What the hell is this?”
Denise looked at her. “You really don't remember?” “Remember WHAT?” “Tonya, we were friends.”
Tonya laughed nervously.
“Friends? Girl, I don't even know you!” Denise's eyes filled with tears. “That's the problem.”Samuel lowered his head. Tonya looked at him.
“Samuel, why am I in a picture with a woman I've never met?”
He hesitated. “Because you've met her before.”
“WHEN?” “Before you and I started dating.” Tonya looked back at the picture.
On the back were four handwritten words.Happy anniversary. Love, Tonya. She recognized the handwriting. It was hers.
“Samuel…”
“Yeah, baby?”
“Why would I write happy anniversary on a picture of the three of us?” Denise looked away. Samuel said nothing. Tonya shook her head.
“See, this is exactly what I'm talking about. Y'all keep looking at each other like somebody's waiting for permission to tell the truth.”
Denise wiped her face. “Because the last time we told you, things didn't end well.”Tonya slowly turned toward her. “The last time?”
Denise nodded.Tonya looked at Samuel.
“Samuel, what the hell have you gotten me into?”
Tonya sat on the couch, trying to make sense of everything. Samuel sat across from her. Denise stood near the kitchen. Nobody said a word. Finally, Tonya broke the silence.
“So let me get this straight. You two are telling me that I knew Denise before I met you, but somehow I don't remember her?”
Samuel nodded.
“Yes.”
“And neither one of you thought that was worth mentioning?”
“Tonya, it wasn't that simple.”She laughed. “Oh, it's never simple when somebody's lying.”Denise spoke.
“Samuel isn't lying about everything.”Tonya turned toward her.
“About EVERYTHING? Girl, what does that even mean?”
“Denise!” Samuel warned.
“No, Samuel. I'm tired of this. I'm tired of pretending like none of this happened.”
Tonya leaned forward.“Then stop pretending and start talking.”Denise took a deep breath.“Three months ago, you disappeared.”Tonya frowned. “Disappeared where?” “That's the thing. Nobody knew.”Tonya looked at Samuel. “Is she serious?”
Samuel nodded. “We looked everywhere for you.”
“For how long?” “Almost two days,”Tonya laughed.
“Okay, now I know y'all are lying. Because I would've remembered something like that.”Denise shook her head. “You didn't remember it the first time either.”
Tonya's smile faded. “What do you mean, the first time?” Before Denise could answer, Tonya's phone vibrated.
Unknown Number.
She stared at the screen. Samuel noticed. “Who's calling you?” “I don't know.” “Don't answer it.” Tonya looked up.
“Excuse me?”
“Tonya, please. Just let it ring.” She answered anyway. “Hello?” Silence!
“Hello? Who is this?”
A woman's voice whispered. “Don't believe them.”Tonya froze. “Who is this?” “Ask Samuel what happened in Room 214.” The call disconnected. Tonya slowly lowered the phone.
Samuel was staring at her. “What did they say?” She looked him dead in his eyes.
“What's Room 214?”
Denise dropped the glass she was holding.
It shattered across the kitchen floor.
Samuel jumped up.
“Denise!”
But Tonya wasn't looking at Denise. She was watching Samuel. Because for the first time that evening, he looked genuinely afraid.
“Samuel, I'm going to ask you one more time. What happened in Room 214?”
He rubbed his forehead. “Tonya, there's a lot you don't understand.” “Then help me understand!”
Denise walked back into the living room. “Samuel, just tell her.” “Denise, stay out of it.”
“No! That's what got us here in the first place. Everybody keeps trying to protect her from something she deserves to know!”
Tonya stood. “Protect me from WHAT?”
Samuel looked at Denise. “Fine. You want to tell her? Go ahead.” Denise stared at Tonya.
“The night you disappeared, Samuel received a call from a hotel.” Tonya frowned.
“A hotel?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
Denise hesitated.
“Because somebody had checked into Room 214 using your name.” Tonya shrugged. “Okay, and?”
“The problem was, you were already home.”
Tonya stopped breathing for a moment.
“What?”
Samuel spoke. “You were sitting right beside me when the hotel called.” Tonya shook her head. “No. That's impossible.”Denise nodded.
“That's what we thought.” Tonya looked from one to the other.
“So somebody stole my identity?” “We don't know,” Samuel answered. Tonya folded her arms.
“Okay, so let me understand this. Somebody checked into a hotel using my name while I was sitting beside you?”
“Yes.” “And instead of calling the police, you did what?” Samuel looked away.
“Samuel?”
“We went to the hotel.” Tonya stared at him.
“WE?”
Denise nodded. “All three of us.”Tonya laughed.
“Oh, this story just keeps getting better. So now we're going on field trips to meet somebody pretending to be me?”
“Tonya, please,” Denise whispered.
“No, seriously! Because at this point, I'm trying to figure out whether y'all think I'm stupid or crazy.”
Samuel stepped closer. “Nobody thinks you're crazy.” “Then stop treating me like I am!” Her phone vibrated again. A text message.
UNKNOWN NUMBER….
Check your purse. Tonya looked down at the purse hanging from her shoulder. She opened it.
Wallet.
Keys.
Lip gloss.
A receipt.
And a small silver key.
Attached to it was a plastic tag.
214.
Tonya stared at it. “Samuel…” He looked down. His entire expression changed.“Where did you get that?”
Tonya slowly looked up. “That's what I was about to ask YOU. ”Denise backed away.
“Oh my God.” Tonya turned toward her.
“What now?” Denise covered her mouth.“That's the same key.”Tonya frowned.“The same key from what?” Denise whispered. “The night you disappeared. ”Tonya looked back at Samuel.He wasn't saying anything. She shook her head.
“You know what? I'm done. Whatever this is, whatever game y'all are playing, I want no parts of it.”
She grabbed her purse and headed toward the door. Samuel followed. “Tonya, don't leave like this.”She turned around. “Samuel, you better be glad all I'm doing is leaving!” “Baby, please.”
“No! You don't get to disappear on me for two days, have me show up here looking like a damn fool, and then start telling me some story about a hotel room and a woman I don't remember!”
Denise called from behind him. “Tonya, please be careful.” Tonya looked over her shoulder. “Girl, at this point, I need to be careful around YOU!”
She slammed the door.
Tonya sat inside her car, gripping the steering wheel.
Her mind was racing.
The picture, hotel room, missing two days.
And that damn key. Nothing made sense.
She reached for her phone. Another message appeared. You shouldn't have gone there.
Tonya typed back. WHO IS THIS?
The response came immediately. Someone who knows what really happened. Tonya rolled her eyes.
THEN PICK UP THE PHONE AND TELL ME!
Three dots appeared. Then it disappeared.
Then another message:
“Look in your rearview mirror.”
Tonya froze. Slowly, she lifted her eyes.
Nothing.
Just the empty street behind her. She let out a nervous laugh. “Oh, hell no. I'm not doing this.”
She started the engine. Her phone rang.
Unknown Number.
This time, she answered without hesitation.
“Listen, whoever this is, you better stop playing on my damn phone!” A woman laughed. Tonya's heart dropped. Because the laugh sounded familiar.
Too familiar.
“Girl, you always did have a mouth on you.”
Tonya swallowed. “Who is this?” “You really don't remember me?” “Remember WHO?”
The woman sighed.
“That's a shame. After everything we've been through.”
Tonya looked around the car. “Listen, I don't know what kind of sick game this is, but…”
“Check your lipstick.”
Tonya frowned.
“What?”
“Your lipstick, Tonya. Look at it.”
She reached into her purse and pulled out her favorite red lipstick.
She removed the cap.
Scratched into the side were two words.
WELCOME BACK.
Tonya dropped it. Her breathing quickened. “Who the hell are you?” The woman laughed again.
Then she said something that made Tonya's entire body go cold.
“Girl, you can stop pretending with me.”
Tonya whispered. “What are you talking about?”
The woman replied. “Samuel wasn't supposed to fall in love with both of us.”
Tonya couldn't speak. Then the woman added:
“And since you want to know who I am so badly…”
A pause.
“Look in the mirror.”
The call ended.
Tonya slowly lifted her eyes toward the rearview mirror. For a moment, she stared at her reflection.
The reflection was indeed hers, there was no denying that. But something about the woman looking back at her felt unfamiliar.
Then her phone vibrated one last time. A photograph appeared. It showed Samuel standing outside Room 214.
His arm was wrapped around a woman. A woman wearing Tonya's red dress. Tonya zoomed in.
The woman's face was turned away. But beneath the picture was a message. “Now ask him which one of us he really loves.” Tonya dropped the phone into her lap.
And for the first time that night, she wasn't sure whether she wanted the truth. Because whatever Samuel had been hiding… It was bigger than another woman.
TO BE CONTINUED




Comments